In Short
- Using both employees and contractors offers flexibility but creates legal and tax risks if roles are not clearly defined.
- Misclassifying contractors can lead to backdated tax, National Insurance, penalties and employment claims.
- IR35 rules place responsibility on many businesses to assess contractor status and deduct tax where required.
Tips for Businesses
Regularly review whether contractors are genuinely independent based on how they work in practice, not just what the contract says. Use clear, separate contracts and processes for employees and contractors, and be cautious about applying employee policies to contractors. Where IR35 applies, document status assessments and seek advice early to reduce tax and tribunal risk.
Table of Contents
- Understanding the Distinction Between Employees and Contractors
- Tax and National Insurance Compliance
- Employment Rights and Entitlements
- Workplace Policies and Procedures
- Health and Safety Obligations
- Administrative Complexity
- IR35 and Off-Payroll Working Rules
- Key Takeaways
- Frequently Asked Questions
As a UK employer, you may choose to build your workforce using a combination of permanent employees and independent contractors. This provides workforce flexibility and can help you manage costs while accessing specialist skills when needed. However, operating with both employees and contractors brings distinct legal challenges that you need to navigate carefully. This article explores the key challenges you might face when managing a mixed workforce and offers guidance on how to address them.
Understanding the Distinction Between Employees and Contractors
The first and most important issue with a mixed workforce is correctly distinguishing between employees and contractors. This distinction is not simply a matter of what you call someone or what their contract states. HMRC and employment tribunals will look at the actual working relationship to determine employment status.
Employees typically work under your control and direction, are integrated into your business, cannot provide a substitute, and have an obligation to accept work you offer them. Contractors, on the other hand, generally have more autonomy over how they complete their work, can refuse assignments, can provide a substitute, and often work for multiple clients simultaneously. Getting this classification wrong can lead to significant problems, including tax liabilities, employment tribunal claims, and penalties from HMRC.
Tax and National Insurance Compliance
One of the most significant risks with a mixed workforce concerns tax and National Insurance contributions. If HMRC decides a contractor should be treated as an employee, you may face backdated tax, National Insurance and penalties.
The IR35 rules (or “Off-Payroll Working”) are relevant if you engage contractors who operate through personal service companies. For tax purposes, you must assess whether a contractor would be an employee if engaged directly. If so, deduct tax and National Insurance before paying them.
Continue reading this article below the formEmployment Rights and Entitlements
Employees enjoy a wide range of statutory rights and protections under UK employment law, including unfair dismissal protection, redundancy pay, minimum notice periods, and the right to request flexible working. Contractors generally do not have these rights. However, if a tribunal finds that a contractor is actually an employee or worker, they may be able to claim these rights retrospectively. This could include claims for holiday pay, the National Minimum Wage, or even unfair dismissal.
Workplace Policies and Procedures
Your workplace policies, such as disciplinary procedures, grievance processes, and codes of conduct, typically apply to employees but not to contractors. However, managing this distinction in practice can be challenging. You may want contractors to adhere to certain standards or behaviours while on your premises or representing your business, but applying employee policies to contractors could suggest they are actually employees.
You need to strike a balance between maintaining appropriate standards and preserving the independent nature of the contractor relationship. This often requires developing separate guidelines or service level agreements for contractors that respect their independent status.
Health and Safety Obligations
Your health and safety obligations extend to both employees and contractors working on your premises or under your control, though the extent of these duties may differ. Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, you must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of all workers, including contractors. However, contractors may also have their own health and safety responsibilities, particularly if they bring their own equipment or control how work is carried out.
Administrative Complexity
Managing a mixed workforce creates additional administrative complexity compared to employing only permanent staff. You need different onboarding processes, payment systems, and record-keeping practices for employees and contractors. Contractors typically invoice for their services rather than being paid through payroll, which requires different financial processes and affects your accounting and tax reporting.
IR35 and Off-Payroll Working Rules
The IR35 legislation, also known as the off-payroll working rules, must be observed when managing contractors. If you are a medium or large organisation in the private sector, or any organisation in the public sector, you are responsible for determining the IR35 status of contractors engaged through their own limited companies.
If you determine that a contractor would be an employee if engaged directly (inside IR35), you must deduct tax and National Insurance from their fees. Making these determinations requires careful assessment of the working arrangements using HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool or obtaining professional advice. Getting these assessments wrong can result in tax liabilities and penalties.
Learn how to manage employment disputes and protect your business from legal action.
Key Takeaways
Managing a mixed workforce of employees and contractors offers significant benefits but requires careful attention to legal compliance and practical management. The most critical issue is correctly determining employment status, as misclassification can lead to substantial tax liabilities and employment claims.
Additionally, you need clear contracts for each type of worker, policies that reflect the differences between employees and contractors, and strong tax compliance processes, particularly under IR35. Regularly reviewing contractor arrangements and seeking advice when needed can further help minimise risk and support your business goals.
LegalVision provides ongoing legal support for UK businesses through our fixed-fee legal membership. Our experienced lawyers help businesses manage contracts, employment law, disputes, intellectual property and more, with unlimited access to specialist lawyers for a fixed monthly fee. To learn more about LegalVision’s legal membership, call 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
The classification depends on the actual working relationship rather than what you call someone. Key factors include the degree of control you exercise over how work is performed, whether there is mutuality of obligation (an obligation to offer and accept work), whether the person can send a substitute, and how integrated they are into your business.
The main risks include backdated tax and National Insurance liabilities, employment tribunal claims for rights such as holiday pay and unfair dismissal, penalties from HMRC, and reputational damage.
True contractors generally do not have employment rights. However, some contractors may qualify as “workers” under UK law, which gives them certain rights such as the National Minimum Wage, holiday pay, and protection from discrimination. The classification depends on the specific working arrangements and contractual terms in place.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
