Table of Contents
Dividends are a crucial mechanism for distributing a company’s profits to its shareholders. For business owners, understanding the legal framework governing dividends is essential to ensure compliance with corporate law and to avoid potential liabilities. Failure to comply with statutory requirements can result in financial penalties and even personal liability for directors. This article will examine the legal aspects of dividends for companies, including statutory requirements, types of dividends, directors’ responsibilities, and potential liabilities for unlawful distributions.
Learn how to meet your directors’ duties and ensure compliance with LegalVision’s free UK Board Reporting Toolkit.
What Are Dividends?
A dividend is a payment made by a company to its shareholders from its post-tax profits. Under the Companies Act 2006 (CA 2006), dividends are classified as distributions, meaning they must be made from available distributable profits as determined by reference to the company’s accounts. A company cannot legally pay dividends if it has accumulated losses or insufficient distributable reserves.
Dividends can be paid in various forms, including:
- Cash Dividends: The most common form of distribution.
- Scrip Dividends: Shareholders receive additional shares instead of cash.
- Dividends in Specie: Payments made in non-cash assets.
- Special Dividends: One-off payments, often linked to extraordinary profits or asset sales.
Final vs. Interim Dividends
Dividends can be classified into final and interim dividends:
- Final dividends are typically declared at the Annual General Meeting, following recommendations by the board, and become payable once approved by the shareholders.
- Interim dividends are declared by the board and paid before the company’s year-end. Unlike final dividends, there is no legal obligation to pay an interim dividend once it has been approved.
Legal Requirements for Declaring Dividends
Before declaring a dividend, a company must ensure that:
- it has sufficient distributable profits, as defined in Section 830 of the CA 2006;
- the distribution complies with the company’s articles of association, which may impose specific restrictions or procedural requirements; and
- the board minutes record the directors’ decision to recommend or declare a dividend, confirming that it is in the company’s best interests.
Directors’ Duties and Liability
Company directors have a duty under Sections 171-174 of the CA 2006 to act in the company’s best interests, exercise reasonable care, and ensure financial prudence when declaring dividends. If unlawful, directors can face personal liability and may be required to repay the company.
Key legal cases highlight these responsibilities:
- Re Exchange Banking Co (1882): Directors were held liable for dividends paid out of capital rather than profits.
- Bairstow v Queens Moat Houses plc (2000): Directors who authorised unlawful dividends had to repay them, even if they acted without fraudulent intent.
- Burnden Holdings (UK) Ltd v Fielding (2019): The Supreme Court ruled that claims against directors for unlawful dividends are not subject to a six-year limitation period.
Common Issues with Dividend Payments
- Unlawful Dividends: If dividends are paid from capital rather than profits, they are considered unlawful, and directors may be personally liable.
- Shareholder Disputes: Disagreements between majority and minority shareholders over dividend payments can lead to litigation.
- Tax implications: Business owners should consider the tax treatment of dividends, which differs from that of salary payments and may impact both personal and corporate tax obligations.
- Changing market conditions: Economic downturns or unexpected financial difficulties can make dividend payments unsustainable, requiring careful financial planning.
- Regulatory scrutiny: Companies that regularly pay high dividends may face increased regulatory attention to ensure compliance with financial regulations.
Avoiding Legal Pitfalls
To avoid legal issues, business owners and directors should:
- review company accounts before declaring dividends to ensure adequate distributable profits;
- consult legal and financial advisors to confirm compliance with corporate law and tax regulations;
- document all decisions in board minutes to establish a clear record of compliance;
- check the company’s articles of association for any restrictions or required procedures;
- consider future financial stability, ensuring that paying dividends does not jeopardise the company’s solvency;
- monitor shareholder agreements to ensure dividend policies align with contractual obligations; and
- stay informed on legal updates to ensure compliance with any changes in corporate law.
Key Takeaways
Dividends must be paid only from distributable profits to comply with the Companies Act 2006. Final dividends require shareholder approval, whereas interim dividends are declared by the board of directors. Directors have a legal duty to ensure that dividends are lawfully declared, or they may face personal liability. Business owners should carefully consider the financial and tax implications of dividend payments. Proper documentation and legal advice are essential to avoid regulatory and financial risks. Companies should maintain robust financial planning to ensure that dividend payments align with long-term sustainability goals.
If you need help with your company’s board, our experienced corporate lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us on 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a company pay dividends if it has no profits?
No, dividends can only be paid from distributable profits. If a company has no available profits, any dividend paid would be unlawful.
What happens if a dividend is found to be unlawful?
If a dividend is unlawfully paid, directors may be held personally liable and required to repay the company.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
