In Short
-
An exclusivity clause restricts one party from working with competitors or entering similar agreements within a set market or timeframe.
-
It must be clearly defined, limited in scope, and proportionate to commercial goals to remain enforceable.
-
Poorly drafted clauses risk breaching competition law or being deemed unfair restrictions on trade.
Tips for Businesses
Define exclusivity terms precisely, include clear time limits, scope and termination rights. Avoid overly broad restrictions and seek legal advice to ensure the clause supports your business objectives without breaching competition law.
Exclusivity clauses can be among the most commercially valuable terms in a business agreement. However, nuanced legal considerations apply when drafting such clauses. As such, it is vital for businesses to carefully consider and understand how exclusivity clauses operate in a commercial agreement and to be aware of the essential drafting considerations surrounding them (including potential risks to their enforceability). This article provides a high-level introduction to key considerations surrounding exclusivity clauses in commercial contracts and how to draft them to help mitigate risk.
What is an Exclusivity Clause?
In simple terms, an exclusivity clause is a contractual provision that grants one party exclusive rights, such as over a particular market, territory, or product. In practice, this means a party has exclusive rights, thereby preventing the other party from engaging in comparable dealings elsewhere. This restriction may be one-sided (benefiting only one party) or mutual.
Essentially, this is to prevent parties from engaging in similar dealings with others (such as competitors) and can therefore be used to ensure business predictability and give commercial parties greater comfort and security.
Download this free Supplier Contracts Checklist to ensure your contracts will meet your business’ needs.
Their Importance
In certain high-value deals, exclusivity can be a protective measure and a vital negotiated commercial right. For example, a customer may agree to source all its requirements for a particular product exclusively from a specific supplier.
Exclusivity can be important in certain agreements, as it can help one party secure a competitive market position. Such clauses can be valuable in a range of commercial relationships where certainty and strategic advantage are key, for example:
- businesses entering into long-term or high-value supply arrangements may want to rely on exclusivity to protect their investment and prevent competitors from accessing the same resources or customers;
- distributors distributing products may seek exclusivity within particular markets; and
- franchisees may seek to use exclusivity terms to define their territorial rights.
Key Legal Issues to Consider When Drafting Exclusivity Clauses
Exclusivity terms should be agreed upon and carefully documented to define the parties’ obligations. For instance, if a supply contract does not expressly contain exclusivity obligations, the customer may freely purchase from other suppliers, and the supplier may freely offer services to the customer’s competitors. Courts are unlikely to imply exclusivity obligations.
Although exclusivity can be commercially advantageous, you must carefully draft exclusivity clauses to ensure their enforceability and compliance with competition laws.
To increase the likelihood that this clause is enforceable, parties must clearly define the scope, the duration of the exclusivity, and the specific parties to whom the provisions apply.
They should also ensure that they carefully draft exclusivity provisions in a proportionate and targeted manner that also aligns with legitimate commercial objectives. Courts will interpret exclusivity clauses strictly in accordance with the specific contract wording. Terms such as “exclusive” or “sole supplier” will not automatically restrict all competitive activity unless the contract expressly identifies what activities the clause prohibits. More specific and proportionate provisions may be more likely to be upheld if challenged, but overly broad restrictions could go beyond what is commercially necessary and create risk.
Exclusivity clauses can also raise competition law concerns. In the UK, such arrangements may be in breach of competition laws if they prevent fair competition. However, where market share is low or the agreement qualifies for an exemption, the risk is lower. If a clause restricts market access too broadly or prevents a party from operating competitively without objective justification, a court or regulator may treat it as an unreasonable restraint.
Continue reading this article below the formWhy Businesses Should Seek Legal Advice
Exclusivity clauses can significantly impact a contracting party’s commercial freedom, and so businesses must carefully evaluate both the commercial and legal implications before agreeing to them.
It is essential to ensure that exclusivity provisions are legally sound and proportionate. Their purpose should be to protect legitimate commercial interests but not to eliminate competition or restrict market access in a way that could breach competition law. The assessment of whether an exclusivity clause is lawful depends on the specific market context and therefore requires careful legal analysis.
As such, legal advice is key. A commercial contracts solicitor can help ensure an exclusivity clause complies with competition laws, is proportionate and legally sound and protects the contracting party’s commercial interests. Where exclusivity is a key requirement or risk for your business, it is advisable to seek legal advice on the specific wording and its implications before entering into your agreement.
Key Takeaways
Exclusivity clauses can be important contractual tools to help protect innovation and create significant long-term value. However (to ensure enforceability), it is crucial to draft these provisions with precision, clearly defining the scope of exclusivity and specifying a proportionate duration. Seeking legal advice from a commercial contracts solicitor before agreeing to exclusivity is a sensible step to ensure the clause is legally sound and does not risk breaching competition law rules.
If you need help reviewing or drafting an exclusivity clause, our experienced contract lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Depending on the context and your goals, agreeing to exclusivity clauses can serve as powerful commercial tools that safeguard your business interests, reduce competitive threats and provide a stronger means for achieving your long-term strategic goals.
A commercial lawyer can carefully review your commercial situation and intentions, draft an explicit exclusivity clause to improve its chances of being held enforceable, and tailor it to align with your commercial interests.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
