Skip to content

What Can Startup Founders Do If Their Co-Founder is Underperforming?

Table of Contents

As a startup founder, you would likely know that managing the relationship between co-founders is essential to navigating your startup’s growth. However, from time to time, unavoidable conflicts can emerge between co-founders. Where you believe a co-founder is underperforming, the co-founders will need to decide what course of action to take to resolve the issue. This article considers some strategies for navigating issues surrounding co-founder underperformance.

Front page of publication
UK Startup Manual

LegalVision’s Startup Manual is essential reading material for any startup founder looking to launch and grow a successful startup.

Download Now

1. Identify the Co-Founder’s Underperformance

The first step is to determine the nature of the other performances and its cause. While the causes of underperformance will largely depend on the circumstances, typical examples include:

  • inadequate attention to detail;
  • failing to meet performance metrics;
  • not spending sufficient working time with the startup; and
  • being overextended by other ventures.

Likewise, the cause of a performance may vary. It may be that the co-founder has certain expectations they cannot meet. This may be because they do not have adequate experience or the technical know-how to operate in their role. Alternatively, it may be due to:

  • conflicts of interest; or 
  • disinterest or personality conflicts.

In any event, you must understand the nature of the underperformance before pursuing any action. 

2. Review All Co-Founder Agreements

Once you have identified the nature of the underperformance, the next step is to see if any legal documents govern the relationship between the cofounders. If your startup is incorporated as a company, which most are, you may have a shareholders’ agreement in place.

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between co-founders separate from the company’s constitution. Most shareholders’ agreements have provisions that detail how cofounders will resolve disputes between themselves. 

For instance, there may be a provision to refer the dispute to a mediator or arbitrator. The agreement may even specify the rights and obligations of co-founders, which, if the co-founder fails to uphold, can indicate their underperformance.

Where an agreement is in place, all parties must follow its procedures. The exception is, of course, if all the parties agree to wave the effect of an existing agreement. To this end, where provisions are in place, and one or more cofounders ignore them, the aggrieved cofounder will have a claim against the offending cofounders for breach of contract.

The same principles apply if your startup is structured as a partnership governed by a partnership agreement.

Continue reading this article below the form
Need legal advice?
Call 0808 196 8584 for urgent assistance.
Otherwise, complete this form and we will contact you within one business day.

3. Take Appropriate Action Against the Co-Founder

What is appropriate depends on the circumstances. Likewise, if a pre-existing agreement governs your co-founder’s obligations, your options may be pre-determined.

In any event, it is always advisable to consider the commercial implications of any course of action. For instance, there may be a provision that enables all of the co-founders to ouster the offending co-founder. If the underperforming cofounder’s conduct is grievous or poses a commercial threat to the business, the right to remove the underperforming cofounder may be the best course of action.

On the other hand, where the underperformance is slight, or the underperforming cofounder has certain rights that limit what the other co-founders can do, attempting to remove the underperforming co-founder may not be advisable or even possible. In this case, it may be worth referring the dispute to an independent third party to evaluate the course of actions available. Mediators are skilled in identifying ways to resolve disputes, including those related to underperformance.

Generally speaking, cofounders owe one another high standards to act in the other cofounders’ best interests. These obligations may be specified in a contract, such as a shareholders’ or partnership agreement. But even without express agreement, the law may imply a duty of good faith in the relationships between you and startup cofounders.

Therefore, you must act in the best interests of your co-founders, including anyone you feel is underperforming. This will limit your liability if the dispute escalates.

Likewise, preserving evidence and documenting the facts surrounding the dispute as clearly as possible is good. Again, this will help clarify any issues if the matter proceeds to a more formal dispute, such as in court or arbitration.

Key Takeaways

If you have an underperforming co-founder, you should:

  • identify the nature and source of underperformance;
  • determine if any agreements in place regulate the rights and obligations of co-founders to one another; and
  • consider the commercial consequences when exercising rights against the underperforming co-founder. 

Ultimately, the commercial consequences may outweigh the advantages of pursuing action against the co-founder.

If you need help with your startup, our experienced startup lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.

Register for our free webinars

Protecting and Enforcing Your Brand

Online
Protect your brand from misuse and infringement. Register for our free webinar.
Register Now

Deal Structures 101: Understanding Equity, ASAs and Convertible Notes

Online
As a startup founder, understand your capital raising options. Register for our free webinar today.
Register Now

Common Legal Pitfalls for SaaS and Online Businesses

Online
Protect your online or SaaS business from common legal pitfalls. Register for our free webinar.
Register Now

GDPR Compliance Essentials for SMEs

Online
Ensure our business is compliant with GDPR and build trust with customers. Register for our free webinar.
Register Now
See more webinars >
Jake Rickman

Jake Rickman

Read all articles by Jake

About LegalVision

LegalVision is an innovative commercial law firm that provides businesses with affordable, unlimited and ongoing legal assistance through our membership. We operate in Australia, the United Kingdom and New Zealand.

Learn more

We’re an award-winning law firm

  • Award

    2024 Law Company of the Year Finalist - The Lawyer Awards

  • Award

    2024 Law Firm of the Year Finalist - Modern Law Private Client Awards

  • Award

    2023 Economic Innovator of the Year Finalist - The Spectator

  • Award

    2023 Law Company of the Year Finalist - The Lawyer Awards

  • Award

    2023 Future of Legal Services Innovation - Legal Innovation Awards