Summary
- An assignment transfers only the rights or benefits under a contract to a third party through an assignment deed, without requiring the consent of all parties unless the contract expressly requires it, and does not terminate the original contract.
- A novation transfers both rights and obligations to a third party, effectively cancelling the original contract and creating a new one, requiring the consent and signatures of all parties including the party exiting the arrangement.
- Novations require consideration for both the termination of the original contract and the creation of the new one, which is why most novations are executed as deeds to avoid the need to demonstrate consideration separately.
- This article is a guide to assignments and novations for business owners in England and Wales, explaining the key differences between these two mechanisms for transferring contractual rights and obligations.
- LegalVision is a commercial law firm that specialises in advising clients on commercial contracts and business transactions.
Tips for Businesses
Determine whether you need to transfer rights only or both rights and obligations before choosing between an assignment and a novation. Check your existing contracts for clauses restricting or prohibiting assignment before proceeding. Execute novations as deeds to avoid complications with consideration requirements, and ensure all parties sign before the transfer takes effect.
When you need to transfer rights or obligations under a contract to a third party, choosing the right legal mechanism is essential. Assignments and novations can both achieve this, but they work in very different ways and carry different requirements. This article will explain the main differences between an assignment and a novation and the circumstances where you may wish to use them.
What is an Assignment?
Under the terms of a standard contractual agreement, your business may receive rights or benefits, such as the right to be paid. You may wish to transfer the right to receive these benefits through an assignment to someone who is not a party to the original agreement. The assignment of the right can be granted to a third party through an assignment deed. This will set out the benefits you wish to bestow on another person. It is worth noting that you can only assign your rights. You cannot assign any rights conveyed in a contract to another person.
Assignments are common in construction contracts where a property developer may enter into a building contract with a contractor. The developer can transfer their rights under that contract to anyone buying the property. Those rights then allow the purchaser to demand the contractor perform their duties under the original arrangement. Otherwise, they can make a claim against the contractor for a breach of contract.
Common examples of assignments in business:
Examples of Assignments in Business
- Intellectual Property Rights: A company may assign ownership of a patent or trade mark to another business.
- Commercial Lease Agreements: A tenant might assign their lease to a new tenant, transferring the right to occupy the property.
These examples illustrate how assignments can be used flexibly across various business contexts to transfer valuable rights and interests.
What is a Novation?
Novations are slightly more complicated than assignments. They transfer both the rights and obligations that you have under a contract. You may use a novation to leave a contract you no longer wish to be a party to where you need to find a replacement to ‘step into your shoes’ as party to the contract. For example, if you stop trading in a specific service or line of goods, you can use a novation deed to remove yourself from a contract to provide these services. The novation deed will then allow you to substitute yourself for someone else willing to do this work.
Technically, a novation cancels the original contract you held with your business partner and creates a duplicate contract. In that duplicate, a third party will take the rights, benefits, and obligations conveyed to you from that agreement.
Novations often occur when businesses are acquired or sold, or when debt transactions are executed. For example, when a company borrows money from a lender and wants to transfer the obligations to repay the debt to a third party, or when a company sells its assets (including contracts) to another business, and needs to novate all client contracts to the purchaser. In these situations, the transfer of these obligations would be agreed via a novation.
It is crucial to understand that novation effectively creates a new contract, which means all parties must agree to the terms. This can be both an advantage and a challenge. On one hand, it allows for a clean break and a fresh start with the new party. On the other hand, it may require extensive negotiation to ensure all parties are satisfied with the new arrangement.
Continue reading this article below the formCall 0808 196 8584 for urgent assistance.
Otherwise, complete this form, and we will contact you within one business day.
Two Key Differences Between an Assignment and a Novation
There are other differences between the two that business owners must be aware of.
1. Novations Require the Consent of All Parties
An assignment does not require the consent of all parties to the contract to transfer the rights, unless there is an express clause in the contract that mandates that assignment can only occur with consent. Additionally, you do not necessarily have to notify the other parties to an agreement that an assignment is taking place. However, as a commercial courtesy, it is wise to notify your business partners that you intend to assign your rights to a third party. It is also essential to ensure that no contractual terms prohibit you from transferring a benefit to a third party. Doing so may result in breaching the contract, and you will be liable for any resulting damages.
With novations, you must obtain consent from every party to a contract before transferring your contractual obligations and rights. This is because you are transferring your duties to perform obligations to a third party. Additionally, as other businesses involved in a contract rely on the performance of these obligations, they have a right to be notified of the novation arrangements. They must also provide their consent to these arrangements. Therefore, a novation deed must be signed and approved by all parties to the original agreement, including the party exiting the contract.
2. Novations Require Consideration
Consideration is an essential element of contract law. It is a legal term referring to the payment of value in exchange for a promise. To have a legally binding contract, there must be some form of consideration passing between the parties. For example, in a delivery contract, one party must pay another party for shipping a set of goods. Without that consideration passing between parties, you cannot have a legally binding contract.
Given that novation of a contract extinguishes the previous contract and creates a new one, consideration would be needed for both the termination of the original contract and the creation of the new contract. Given that this can be tricky to organise, most novations are done by way of a deed, so that consideration is not needed.
On the other hand, since assignments do not involve the termination of a contract and the creation of a new one, you do not have to demonstrate that the parties to the contract exchanged consideration, and a deed is often not required.
It is important to note that while consideration is required for novations, it doesn’t necessarily have to be monetary. In some cases, the mutual release of obligations under the original contract can be considered sufficient consideration for the novation to be effective.
If you are moving out of your leased space and assigning the lease to another party, you are required to notify your landlord and obtain their consent. Use this free proforma template for this purpose.
Key Takeaways
Assignments and novations differ in three important ways. For instance, assignments transfer rights to contractual benefits to third parties, while novations transfer rights and obligations under a contract to a third party. Additionally, novations require the consent of all parties to the contract. On the other hand, you can make assignments without the consent of all parties. Finally, novations require consideration, as they involve the termination of one contract in order to create another.
When deciding between an assignment and a novation, consider:
- The nature of what you’re transferring (rights only or rights and obligations)
- The willingness of other parties to consent to the transfer
- The need for a clean break from the original contract
If you need help transferring your rights, LegalVision provides ongoing legal support for all businesses through our fixed-fee legal membership. Our experienced contract lawyers help businesses manage contracts, employment law, disputes, intellectual property, and more, with unlimited access to specialist lawyers for a fixed monthly fee. To learn more about LegalVision’s legal membership, call 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Assignments are a mechanism by which business owners can transfer a right or benefit granted to them under a contractual arrangement to a third party.
A novation transfers both a business owner’s rights and obligations under a contract to a third party.
Technically yes, unless the contract requires consent for assignment. However, notifying business partners of an intended assignment is commercially courteous and helps avoid potential contractual breaches.
Novations suit situations requiring a complete exit from a contract, such as business sales or acquisitions. Assignments better suit situations where you wish to transfer specific rights whilst retaining some contractual involvement.
We appreciate your feedback – your submission has been successfully received.
