The American Cyanamid Test: Injunctions and Contract Remedy Considerations for Small Businesses 

If your business faces an urgent legal issue relating to a breach of contract, you may need to act fast to prevent serious harm. An injunction can be a key remedy to stop urgent harm, such as a competitor misusing your confidential information. But, the courts will not just hand out injunctions – you must prove you need one and satisfy key legal principles. For interim injunctions, judges apply the American Cyanamid test, which can be challenging to meet. The American Cyanamid principles are essential for businesses to understand.  Knowing how the English courts consider such cases and the legal challenges that can arise when seeking injunctive relief is helpful.

Injunctions can also be expensive and come with financial risks. Because injunctions can be tricky to obtain, it is sensible for your business to take early preventative steps to avoid serious contract breaches. A strong contract can help you set clear expectations, prevent misunderstandings, and give you potent legal remedies where things do not go as planned. This article explores contract remedies, how the American Cyanamid test works for injunctions, the challenges of getting an injunction, and why strong contracts are vital to prevent risk rather than relying on remedies.

What Can You Do if a Party Breaches Your Contract?

If the other party breaches your contract, you may be able to claim damages. To do so, you must prove the breach caused financial loss and show that you took reasonable steps to reduce the damage. Keeping records might help you build a stronger case.

In some situations, you can terminate the contract entirely. But you should be careful – if you end a contract without valid legal grounds, the other party could take action against your business. 

Sometimes, even financial compensation is not enough. If the other party is about to commit a serious breach, an injunction might be the only way to stop them. For example, if a company is about to leak your confidential business information, money will not fix that damage. In such cases, an injunction can be your only practical option to avoid the harm.

How Do Interim Injunctions and the American Cyanamid Test Work?

An interim injunction is a temporary court order that stops the other party from doing something (or forces them to take a specific action) until the court makes a final decision before trial. Judges do not grant them lightly. 

Under the American Cyanamid test (American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd), judges consider key criteria before granting an interim injunction, which includes:

• is there a serious issue that needs to be tried?
• would financial damages be an adequate remedy here?

Where there is not an adequate remedy, the court will need to consider all relevant factors and weigh the ‘balance of convenience’ and who would suffer, as well as unique characteristics. 

How to Manage a Business Dispute

This fact sheet outlines how your business can manage a dispute.

Download Now

While these summarise the general principles, you can seek legal advice from a dispute resolution lawyer for full information on the case, its application, and any nuances to be aware of.

Since injunctions are an equitable remedy, judges expect you to act fairly, reasonably, and without delay.  

If you are dealing with a contract dispute or considering applying for an injunction, do not wait until things spiral out of control – instead, make sure you seek legal advice early. A lawyer can help you explore all your options, avoid unnecessary risks, and decide the best course of action.

How Can You Prevent Disputes With a Strong Contract?

Since injunctions can be challenging to obtain, it is vital to take early steps to avoid disputes before they happen. A firm, well-drafted contract can make it easier to enforce your rights and harder for the other party to argue their way out of key obligations.

If expectations are vague in your contracts, disputes become more likely. That is why negotiating and clarifying terms upfront is so important. In commercial agreements – for instance, it is vital to clearly set out how the other party is permitted to use your company’s confidential information or intellectual property rights – setting out clear parameters to avoid misuse. Restrictive covenants may also help prevent damaging harm. Such terms could prevent problems from arising, which may otherwise result in the need for an injunction. 

Once the contract is signed, you should also actively monitor performance, communicate with the other party, and ensure compliance. This can help you identify problem issues early and resolve them before they escalate.

Many businesses may feel they can rely on general contract templates, but these often fail to cover your business’s specific risks. A commercial contracts lawyer can help you draft a legally sound, enforceable agreement that protects your business. A well-drafted contract will help make disputes less likely and give you stronger legal options if the other party does not meet their obligations.

Key Takeaways

Injunctions can be powerful and sometimes necessary, but they are complex remedies to obtain. Courts only grant them if strict legal tests are met—including the American Cyanamid test when considering interim injunctions. Because of these risks, it is essential to take early steps to help prevent contract breaches before they happen. A well-drafted contract will help protect your business by setting clear expectations and may stop serious problems from arising later. 

If you need legal advice or help with contracts, our experienced contract lawyers can assist as part of our LegalVision membership. For a low monthly fee, you will have unlimited access to lawyers to answer your questions and draft and review your documents. Call us today on 0808 196 8584 or visit our membership page.

Frequently Asked Questions